When a business is sold in Florida—whether a Miami restaurant, a healthcare practice, or an industrial services company—the first major decision is how the transaction will be structured: as an asset sale or as a stock purchase. This choice shapes tax consequences, liability exposure, closing mechanics, and even deal valuation.
Because Florida companies often operate with specialized licensing, owner-driven operations, and limited formal financials, choosing the right structure is critical for both sides of the transaction.
⸻
1. Asset Sales: Control, Liability Protection, and Tax Advantages
An asset sale allows the buyer to acquire selected components of the business: equipment, intellectual property, customer relationships, goodwill, and other operational assets. The buyer generally does not take on corporate liabilities unless expressly negotiated.
Liability Containment
Buyers in Florida frequently prefer this structure because they can avoid inheriting:
• tax liabilities,
• unpaid payroll or wage claims,
• vendor disputes,
• pending litigation,
• or regulatory violations.
This is especially important in industries like hospitality, medspa services, construction, and transportation where operational risks tend to accumulate over time.
Tax Benefits Through a Basis Step-Up
Asset deals also provide a meaningful tax advantage:
the buyer receives a new tax basis in the acquired assets, tied to the purchase price allocation.
That higher basis—often described as a “step-up”—allows the buyer to:
• depreciate tangible assets over a new schedule, and
• amortize goodwill and eligible intangibles.
In industries where equipment, leasehold improvements, or substantial goodwill drive enterprise value, the ability to reset basis can materially affect post-closing cash flow and valuation modeling.
Flexibility in What Is (and Isn’t) Acquired
Asset sales let buyers decline to assume unfavorable contracts, choose which employees to hire, or renegotiate landlord relationships. In Florida, where landlord consent and licensing transfers can vary dramatically by municipality, that flexibility can be decisive.
⸻
2. Stock Purchases: Continuity and Simplicity—With Broader Risk
In a stock purchase, the buyer acquires the equity interests of the corporation or LLC. The entity continues uninterrupted, owning the same assets and bearing the same liabilities as before the sale.
Continuity of Operations
Because the entity remains in place, licenses, permits, contracts, and relationships generally transfer without needing new approvals. This is often the most significant advantage of a stock deal in Florida industries such as:
• restaurants and bars (alcohol licensing),
• medspas and clinics (healthcare-related registrations),
• logistics and fleet operations,
• construction and trades requiring state licensing.
For some of these businesses, reapplying for permits or re-credentialing providers can take weeks or months—delays that a stock purchase avoids.
Tax Treatment for the Seller
Sellers often prefer stock sales because the gain is usually treated as a capital gain, and the structure simplifies how proceeds are distributed. For S-corporation shareholders, a stock sale typically produces a single level of tax rather than entity-level tax followed by shareholder-level tax.
No Automatic Basis Step-Up for the Buyer
One significant limitation:
the buyer generally does not receive a step-up in the basis of the company’s assets.
The company keeps its historic basis, meaning the buyer receives:
• the stock with its own purchase-price basis, but
• not fresh depreciation or amortization deductions on the underlying assets.
There are elections—used in specific circumstances—that can emulate an asset sale for tax purposes, but these require negotiation and can shift tax burdens back onto the seller.
All Liabilities Remain
Because the legal entity continues unchanged, the buyer inherits the entire liability profile of the company, disclosed and undisclosed. This makes diligence in stock deals deeper, broader, and often more expensive.
⸻
3. S-Corporation Considerations in Florida Transactions
S-corporations are extremely common across Florida, especially in small and mid-sized businesses. But S-corp rules impose ownership restrictions that influence deal structure.
Ownership Limitations
S-corps cannot have:
• non-resident alien shareholders,
• most corporate or LLC shareholders,
• large shareholder groups,
• certain ineligible trusts.
Because Miami attracts foreign capital—and many strategic buyers use corporate holding structures—these restrictions often make stock purchases impracticalunless the buyer is willing and eligible to maintain S-status.
When an Asset Sale Becomes Mandatory
If the buyer is a foreign individual or a business entity, they may not be eligible to hold S-corp stock at all. In those cases:
• a stock purchase is off the table, and
• the deal must be structured as an asset sale, even if the seller would prefer a stock transaction for tax reasons.
These ownership rules are one of the main reasons asset sales dominate Florida lower-middle-market transactions.
⸻
4. Choosing the Right Structure
No two Florida transactions are identical, but the decision often comes down to competing priorities:
Buyers tend to prefer asset sales when they want:
• minimized liability exposure,
• enhanced tax deductions via basis step-up,
• control over which assets and contracts they assume.
Sellers tend to prefer stock sales when they want:
• favorable capital-gains treatment,
• smoother transition of licenses and contracts,
• the simplest path to distributing proceeds.
The right structure usually emerges through negotiation, driven by the operational realities of the business, the tax profiles of the parties, and the regulatory environment in which the company operates.
